Should my requests be general or specific, or a little of both?

We often hear from members that they don't know what is reasonable to request. Exchanges can run the gamut from very specific tech help to general activities such as a ride somewhere.

Maybe you have a request for cookies or maybe you have a request for gluten-free, non-dairy, sugar-free cookies. Two very different requests and there are different ways to request them.

You could request 2 dozen homemade cookies needed by a certain date. If you take this tactic, you may have several people respond. Then you share your specific requirements. You may find some are very comfortable making a recipe you provide or with constraints you desire while others may pass on the request once you share the details. OR, you post a request for a specific kind of cookie you need with the details in the initial request. This might produce fewer responses, but from people who are experienced making those kinds of cookies or are willing to give it a try. Either way it works! They just create different responses. And feel free to have fun with your posting: Cookie Monster goes Vegan. Make me some cookies, please!